Hospitals are places where lives are supposed to be saved. We enter them because of some pain, hurt, or maybe our body has changed unexpectedly, and a diagnosis is needed, or we feel someone possesses knowledge that we do not have and can save us. Moving in this direction, we consent to examinations and test results and allow strangers to touch the body, medicate, anaesthetise, open, image, monitor, or keep it alive. For an expert to diagnose, we must consent to sharing our test results. Much of this is then possible because medicine depends upon trust. Perhaps this is also why hospitals are so good at scaring us in fiction. Medical thrillers have long drawn their narrative energy from the specialised world of medicine, incorporating professional knowledge, procedures, settings, and ethical questions into suspense (Charpy, 424, 427). These narratives therefore occupy an uneasy space between medical knowledge and the fears that accompany it. However, rereading these novels after becoming a patient led me to ask what happens to the person whose life medicine reorganises.
I had thought about hospitals for years before I became a patient admitted for a C-section in one. When I was about twenty-one, I read Robin Cook’s Coma, Brain, and the Terminal. At first, what fascinated me was not fear or the possibility of foul play. I was in awe of medicine itself. I was drawn to what doctors could diagnose and do, how doctors, patients, and families could understand disease, and how medicine could cure it. Something about medical knowledge and technology seemed beyond my ordinary comprehension. I was fascinated by the way Cook brought the specialised world of medicine and medical research into popular fiction, making its possibilities accessible to a general reader (Stookey 18–19).
When I first encountered Nancy in Coma: A Novel, lying comatose, I did not immediately think something sinister had happened to her. I thought it might be a rare disease or some undiagnosed medical complication. I felt for Nancy, someone around my age. She was young and otherwise healthy, with dreams, desires, and hopes. I could not articulate why the interruption of her life affected me so much. I wanted Nancy to wake up and return to ordinary life. Only later did I encounter critical readings of Coma that helped me understand how strongly the novel is bound to cultural anxieties about medical technology, vulnerability, and the definition of life (Belling 443–44).
I did not begin with theory. I read, stayed with the texts, noticed contradictory feelings and responses, and then searched for a theory that could explain them. I was awed by medicine, the people, the contradictions, the experiences, and so much more, and I wanted to find a theory through which I could understand it. I worked with ideas of liminality and the abject as her comatose state lingered in my mind well after. I became interested in bodies and situations that were difficult to classify: health and illness, life and death, self and other, human and object.
The grotesque became useful because it allowed me to think about these dualisms. Medicine could be both healing and. The doctor could be caregiver and violator. Technology could be life-saving and potentially life-threatening. The body could be protected and exploited. Scientific knowledge could be liberating and dangerous. The hospital could be a place of life and a place of death. These contradictions were central to my earlier readings of medical thrillers through the grotesque (Fernandez and Nayak, 2016).
My doctoral research eventually became Organ Heist Medical Thrillers: A Grotesque Perspective. I loved the protagonists and hated the antagonists, but I also began noticing that the antagonists saw medicine through an alternative lens. I did not ethically approve of what they did, but I could understand some of their reasoning. The grotesque gave me a way of thinking about these contradictions without reducing them to simple oppositions.
Then I became a patient. It is not that I have never been admitted to a hospital. This time, I was admitted for a C-section. I remember the smell, the lights, the tubes, and the huge machines that the doctor brought in to check the baby, scan, and listen to the heartbeat. I was afraid, nervous, curious, and reassured at the same time. The doctor was especially comforting. She touched my hands and spoke in a low, warm voice. She showed me the baby moving on the scan and reassured me. I remember the warmth of her presence against the steel of the medical instruments. Her voice and warmth resonated with the shared feeling of seeing the baby on the screen. I felt safe, and I did not feel alone.
Under the epidural, I did not feel pain, but I felt the coldness and the shivering. I could hear conversations. My mind went through biology lessons and things I had read. I wondered what the surgeons were doing and where they were reaching toward. In my mind, I visualised the cold steel of the knives cutting me like a saw. Then I perceived a sudden tug in my tummy and a rush of emptiness. It was not simply fear. I was also curious about what was happening inside my own body. I felt proud that I had read about the procedure and could understand some of it. At the same time, I worried about whether everything would be fine afterwards. I realised I could know something about medicine and still never know everything happening inside my own body.
Before this experience, I had thought of the hospital as a complex space. It could protect you but, at the same time, it could be your place of death. Life and death could exist in the same place. Nevertheless, being there made the hospital more than that. It became a place full of people, voices, gestures, waiting, relationships, and care. I could breathe, smell and sense everything there. The C-section turned into a story or an event full of people, voices and much more. I started to understand the medical event as something that did not belong only to the patient. It was also lived by the people who waited, watched, worried, reassured, cared, and sometimes learned about parts of it only later.
My husband was actually pacing up and down the corridor while I was in labour. I only learned about it after I returned to our room in the hospital. My neighbour and friend from the hospital, Neethu’s mom, told me. With his limited knowledge of my mother tongue, he had to understand and guess at the whole situation. My father stood silently but nervously in a corner, observing and nodding. There was so much to notice. After the surgery, one of the doctors joked that we looked like a lovely couple and had a lovely baby. There were personal exchanges. I remembered the doctor’s voice during the operation because she was trying to ease the tension. Those who operated on me, their words before and after the procedure, and even the personal conversations stayed with me. The medical event existed in several people’s experiences. I learned some parts only afterwards. This changed how I reread the medical thrillers that had stayed with me for years.
When I returned to Coma, I kept thinking about Nancy. At twenty-one, I had felt vulnerability, sympathy, and helplessness for her. I wanted someone to touch her, reassure her, explain what was happening, and recognise her as a young woman and a person. My own experience made Nancy easier to relate to. I could imagine her lying there, her body being examined, touched, moved, exposed, monitored, and acted upon while she trusted all the medical professionals.
The encounter with the gynaecologist in Coma became different for me too. I could now understand the exposure involved: allowing someone to examine your body, allowing instruments to enter it to determine whether everything is okay, being vulnerable and helpless while looking up at the doctor. The medical encounter involved an asymmetry of knowledge and authority, but also a form of trust (Belling 443–45).
The scene at Jefferson stayed with me for another reason. The image of “marionettes in the strings at Jefferson” was unforgettable. The patients were devoid of basic dignity, stripped of their names and reduced to numbers. Living only by a number felt to me like living in prison for a crime. The narratives reduce them to a storehouse of body parts, depriving them of ordinary human life and the chance to move forward. This reduction of persons to bodies and organs is also central to critical discussions of Coma and its anxieties about medical technology and the treatment of the living and the dead (Belling 443–46).
Somehow, living forward became more important. I began thinking about Spencer in The Donation. I loved the possibility that Spencer could return to ordinary life, even though what happened to him had altered him. He was no longer only Spencer the judge. He became a more humbled Spencer, someone who understood vulnerability, ordinary life, and the need to live forward. Beth holding his hand mattered to me. His encounter with Otis mattered. His turning toward the future mattered. For me, it was in all three.
Spencer seemed to be on the verge of psychological collapse. Without Beth and without the revelation and conversation with Otis, he might not have been able to move beyond what had happened. These encounters allowed him to accept what had happened and move on with gratefulness, rather than keep looking back at the different Spencer he had been before. Finally, he moved on.
Becoming a patient made me realise the importance and value of life lived forward. There was the baby, the life waiting after the operation, bodily vulnerability, recovery, and carrying the experience into the life that follows. All of it mattered. I kept thinking of Nancy too. I wanted her to live a happy life with Kim, to have her dreams, her career, and everything she could do by living. I kept thinking about what could happen if she woke up and returned to that life. This also changed the way I thought about Harvest. Nina starts thinking and “dreaming” about the boy. My first response was just, yes, she was involuntarily drawn into another person’s life without knowing it. I began to think about how relationships can occur only in a hospital, continue after a medical event, or never continue at all.
Spencer and Chalmers have Beth. Nancy and Kim cannot continue because Nancy never wakes up. Nina and Aleksei never meet, but she knows and feels him through the heart. The medical body therefore no longer seemed sufficient. I started seeing the characters as whole persons, people with lives beyond and before or after medicine. This did not erase the grotesque body that had been central to my earlier work; rather, it made me ask what remained outside that body, and what happened to the person who inhabited it (Fernandez and Nayak; Fernandez, Upendra, and Nayak). I started observing the doctors, attendants, nurses, carers, and more. This was perhaps when I began to see medical thrillers differently.
Medical thrillers have generally been discussed through their medical settings, professional knowledge, procedures, representations of doctors, and the sociocultural world of medicine (Charpy 424, 431–32). However, they were not only about medical bodies, medical plots, or solving mysteries. I began to see them as stories about people whose lives are reorganised by medicine. A medical event can alter identity, relationships, memory, vulnerability, and the possibility of returning to ordinary life. The medical event does not necessarily end when the procedure ends.
I had been fascinated by medicine from the beginning, but I was now thinking about medical knowledge differently. I could understand something about the procedure and remain vulnerable to what I could not know. Medical knowledge could reassure me, but it could not completely replace embodied experience.
The hospital also became a relational space for me. My experience was not only about the baby or the operation. It was the doctor’s reassurance, my family’s presence, my husband waiting outside, Neethu’s mother telling me what had happened, the procedure itself, my own knowledge, and the relief afterwards. The whole experience was made up of several of these things. I began to ask what I had been searching for all these years without knowing. It was simply human experience. That realisation did not make my earlier research wrong. I still value what I discovered through the grotesque, liminality, and abjection. (Fernandez and Nayak; Fernandez, Upendra, and Nayak) However, I began to feel that these fictions were more than what I had discovered in my doctoral research, and that was it.
There was something more. You can get cured because of a complication, but then life changes completely. A medical intervention can carry contradictions. It can help a lot of people and yet remain an anxiety-generating space. Medicine can offer a cure, knowledge, technological possibility, and reassurance, while also reminding us how little we can truly know about our own bodies. This is also where the medical thriller began to look different to me as a genre.
The suspense is not only whether the person will survive the medical event. It is also what kind of life, relationship, identity, or memory will exist after the event. The medical event can become a point from which a person has to live forward. At one point, it makes us think of our own lives, vulnerability, relationships, and medicine as science and much more. By “much more,” I mean the fascinating world of medical science, its discoveries, its complexity, and the difficulty of comprehending everything that medicine makes possible.
At one point, I thought of giving up research and focusing more on teaching. However, my hospital experience changed my mind. I reread the books, and they became compelling in a different way. I started looking at medical thrillers not simply as stories of doctors, hospitals, diseases, or medical danger. I began to see them as narratives of medical encounters and their consequences: encounters between patients and doctors, bodies and technologies, knowledge and uncertainty, care and vulnerability, and people whose lives continue, or sometimes fail to continue, after medicine. This is where I began to think about Medical Thriller Studies.
I do not see Medical Thriller Studies as another label for fiction that contains medical themes, but as a way of asking what happens when medicine becomes central to narrative encounter. What happens when medical knowledge becomes suspenseful? What happens when a patient’s body must be trusted and surrendered to experts? What happens when care and danger occupy the same institutional space? What happens to a person’s identity and relationships after a medical event? Existing scholarship has already shown that medical thrillers engage with medical discourse, practices, procedures, and the sociocultural world of medicine (Charpy 431–32), while readings of Coma have revealed how the genre can crystallise anxieties surrounding medical technology and health care (Belling 443–46). My earlier work used the grotesque perspective because I was trying to understand unresolved contradictions in medicine. But my experience as a patient did not remove those contradictions; rather, they became more embodied. I realised the doctor could be reassuring and still hold authority over my body. The hospital turned into a place of safety and a place where I became intensely aware of my own vulnerability. Technology could reassure me through the image and heartbeat of my baby and, at the same time, remind me that so much of what was happening inside my body was inaccessible. Medical knowledge could help me understand the procedure without letting me fully know the experience.
References
Belling, Catherine. “The Living Dead: Fiction, Horror, and Bioethics.” Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, vol. 53, no. 3, 2010, pp. 439–451. https://doi.org/10.1353/pbm.0.0168.
Charpy, Jean-Pierre. “Medical Thrillers: Doctored Fiction for Future Doctors?” Journal of Medical Humanities, vol. 35, no. 4, 2014, pp. 423–434. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10912-014-9305-5.
Fernandez, Jasmine. Organ Heist Medical Thrillers: A Grotesque Perspective. Indian Institute of Technology Indore, 2019.
Fernandez, Jasmine, C. Upendra, and Amarjeet Nayak. “A New Critical Notice of Robin Cook’s Medical Thriller ‘Coma.’” SOCRATES, vol. 6, nos. 3–4, 2018, pp. 1–26. https://doi.org/10.5958/2347-6869.2018.00012.2.
Fernandez, Jasmine C., Upendra, and Amarjeet Nayak. “From Word to Image: Depth Perception, Graphic Narrative and Double-Effect in ‘Coma.’” Brolly: Journal of Social Sciences, vol. 2, no. 2, 2019, pp. 87–102.
Fernandez, Jasmine, and Amarjeet Nayak. “‘Structure, Image and Ideas at Play’: A Revisitation into the Select Medical Thrillers from a Grotesque Lens.” Journal of Science, Humanities and Arts, vol. 3, no. 5, 2016. https://doi.org/10.17160/josha.3.5.234.
Stookey, Lorena Laura. Robin Cook: A Critical Companion. Greenwood Press, 1996.
