EXPERIENCE

The Capacity to Aspire in Government Classrooms in Maharashtra, India

“What do you want to become when you grow up?”

We asked this simple and slightly reflective question during a focus group discussion (FGD) with students at a Zila Parishad1 (ZP) school in Maharashtra, India. At the time, I thought of it as just an ice-breaking activity to help the students feel comfortable. I did not realise that their answers would stay with me long after we left the school.

I am currently working as a research associate with Leadership for Equity, a Pune-based non-profit organisation working on public education. We2 are conducting a research project on gender biases in government classrooms. As part of the project, my colleague and I visited 12 government schools across Maharashtra and conducted FGDs with students from Grades 3 to 5 between July and August 2026. During the discussion, we asked children whether they liked school, what they liked and disliked, and what they wanted to become. Here, I use the answers from three of these schools, one each in Pune, Nagpur, and Nashik districts. Together, 54 students participated across the three FGDs. The gender composition involved 25 girls and 29 boys.

During the FGD, students shared their aspirations, and after listening to them, some answers seemed common, such as doctor, teacher, police officer, army officer, and engineer. Children across the districts repeatedly named a small group of socially familiar professions. I assumed that gender shaped these answers substantially. Similarly, we experienced in the field that girls often mentioned becoming teachers or doctors, while boys more frequently mentioned that they wanted to be police, cricketers, and join the Army profession. Still, the broader pattern was hard to ignore: children were not inventing these associations or professions. They were repeating the highly gendered occupational world they observe through their surrounding physical and virtual world, including their homes, villages, schools, and social media , where certain jobs were visibly associated with women and others with men. Drawing on an intersectional framework, Hata (2026) explains how caste, class, and gender intersect to shape students’ aspirations, while unequal access to social and cultural privileges influences children’s experiences and aspirations.

Application of the intersectional framework in understanding aspirations reveals that future aspirations or imagination are closely shaped by caste, class, gender, region, access to media, and so on. For instance, in Pune’s school, among 25 students, we witnessed 13 different aspirations, including lawyer, boxer, bodybuilder, YouTuber, and reel creator/star. In contrast, in Nagpur and Nashik, the groups were smaller, with 15 and 14 students; the range was narrower. Tell their aspirations first. I want to point out here that these were group discussions, and children heard each other. When one boy says cricketer, others may be influenced by or follow his friend. The groups were small and purposively selected, with one school per district to conduct FGDs. I treat these numbers as patterns to think with, not as findings about Maharashtra. Instead, the differences raise a more important question: what shapes the range of futures children can imagine?

Aspirations need a map

This is where Appadurai’s (2004) Concept of the “capacity to aspire” becomes useful. He argues that aspirations are unevenly distributed because people have unequal access to the experiences and resources that enable them to imagine possible futures. People with fewer resources, by contrast, have fewer such pathways to observe and fewer opportunities to explore them. Bourdieu’s (1986) idea of social and cultural capital similarly highlights that knowing which opportunities exist, and how to access them, is itself a form of capital. Such knowledge is acquired through families, schools, social networks, and everyday exposure rather than through individual ability alone. Schools in Maharashtra operate within this broader environment. What kind of discussions and guidance students receive from teachers, the people and occupations they encounter, media, exposure, and their access to opportunities may all play a role in shaping students’ career aspirations.

Research on children’s aspirations in the Global South similarly shows that what children imagine for their future is closely shaped by the people around them, family expectations, social norms, local realities, political economy, and the opportunities they see as possible (Hata, 2026). Seen this way, drawing from the FGD discussion, when a child, more specifically a girl child, says ” I want to be a teacher,” it is not lacking ambition. She is naming the most visible option within her reach.

My own version of the same answer

After returning from fieldwork, I started working on field notes and data, and found myself reflecting on my own education journey. Fifteen to sixteen years ago, I was one of these children. I studied in a Zila Parishad school in rural India, and when adults asked my friends and me what we wanted to become? My friends and I gave the same replies. Teacher, nurse, doctor, collector. Most of us did not really know what we wanted because we had not been exposed to many opportunities. They were the only professions and career paths we knew. Nobody was there to guide and mentor us to navigate a career path.

My aspirations changed gradually as I moved from my village and later my region for higher education. I entered new institutions, met people from different backgrounds, encountered new ideas, and began to understand pathways that had previously been invisible to me. Over time, I developed forms of social and cultural capital that I had not grown up with. I eventually completed my first master’s degree at the Tata Institute of Social Sciences in India and my second at the University of Edinburgh in the UK.

Looking back on this path, I do not think I suddenly became more capable. What changed was the world I could see and the people and opportunities I could access. These opened pathways that I had not known existed and helped me understand how to navigate them. As Malkani and Rose (2018) note, limited access to resources and support can constrain students’ progress. In contrast, many of my school friends followed more familiar career paths, with several working as engineers or in the informal sector, while many of my female classmates entered teaching, tailoring, beauty services, or home-based work. This contrast reminds me that aspirations are shaped not simply by individual ability or effort, but by the opportunities, networks, and social-cultural capital available to us.

A recent experience gave me another way to think about this.

In Sept 2026, I attended a felicitation ceremony organised by the Eklavya India Foundation, which supported me during my master’s studies. I now volunteer with the organisation as a mentor to students from marginalised communities. Students at the ceremony had travelled from remote hamlets, tribal settlements and villages across Maharashtra. As they introduced themselves, I heard stories of first-generation learners securing fully funded admissions to top QS-ranked3 universities abroad. Many came from families where they were the first-generation learners and from places where information about such opportunities is difficult to access. For many of them, no one in their immediate surroundings had taken a similar path or could show them how to get there. Tambe and Dyahadroy (2023) show that first-generation students often have strong parental hopes but may lack the practical guidance and support needed to realise them. In their study, workers’ organisations helped bridge this gap through mentoring and guidance.

Those scholars’ journeys read to me like Appadurai’s (2004) argument in practice. What changed these students’ futures was not a sudden burst of ambition. They gained a map: people who had made the journey, information they could trust, and mentors who explained the steps. In Bourdieu’s (1986) terms, the programme gave them access to a kind of social and cultural capital that their families and villages could not. We also need to consider that these students are a selected group. They show that exposure and mentorship can change a path, not how often that happens. But after that event, I was still thinking, every child deserves someone or a mentor to show the road and guide them to achieve their ambitions and dreams.

This experience brought me back to a question that had been running through my mind since the fieldwork: who gets to know what is possible? We often assume that phones, social media, edtech, and artificial intelligence have opened up the world for everyone. But access to information is not equal, and information alone does not tell a child what to do with it. Children grow up with very different people, institutions, opportunities, resources, and examples around them. My own journey made this clear to me. Higher education gave me more than academic knowledge. It gave me access to people, ideas, vision, and pathways that had previously been outside of my world. In that sense, resources, mentorship, social and cultural capital mattered. It helped me understand not only what was possible, but also how to move towards it.

Our fieldwork made me look at children’s aspirations differently. The question is whether children have ambitions, or whether they have enough opportunities to develop and expand them. Gender, geography and socio-cultural background shape the people children meet, the professions they encounter and the pathways they can imagine. This has important implications for schools and policymakers. If we want to broaden children’s horizons, providing devices or information is only one part of the answer.

What schools can do

Schools can broaden students’ aspirations through concrete forms of exposure and support. They can invite people from varied professions, especially women in jobs children do not expect to see them in. Organise exposure visits, take children to colleges and workplaces, teach career pathways from the middle grades. Schools can also connect students with mentors from similar backgrounds and with local organisations like those Tambe and Dyahadroy (2023) describe. But exposure alone is insufficient; aspirations are also shaped by the social, economic, cultural, and political world around us. As Malkani and Rose (2018) show, aspirations depend on whether children have the material conditions to pursue opportunities for affordable transport and reliable teacher attendance to accessible schools and workplaces. Policy must therefore address both what children can see and what they can realistically reach. Education can then do more than prepare students for employment. It can widen choices, build agency, and challenge socially inherited limits on what seems possible.

References

Appadurai, A. (2004). The capacity to aspire: culture and terms of recognition. In Rao, V. and Walton, M. (Eds.), Culture and Public Action (pp. 59-84). Stanford University Press.

Bourdieu, P. (1986). The Forms of Capital. In J. Richardson (Ed.), Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education (pp. 241-258). New York: Greenwood Press.

Hata, A. (2026). Hidden aspiration, contradictory agency, and children’s agency in forming situated, intersectional and intergenerational solidarities. Children’s Geographies, 1-15. https://doi.org/10.1080/14733285.2026.2662325.

Malkani, R., & Rose, R. (2018). Learning from the voices of first-generation learners in a remote community of Maharashtra, India. International Journal of Whole Schooling, 14(2), 104-127.

Tambe, A., & Dyahadroy, S. (2023). Breaking through the intergenerational cycle of educational inequalities: First-generation learners, stigmatized occupational groups, and sustainable futures. TESF India, IIHS.

About the Contributor
Nikita Dadabhai Sonawane
Leadership for Equity
India

Nikita is a researcher and development practitioner. Her work domain focuses on gender, inequality, social justice and entrepreneurship.

The Capacity to Aspire in Government Classrooms in Maharashtra, India